Italian Food in Fenway, Boston

Pizza, pasta, and paninis anchor Italian food at Cappy's Pizza & Subs in Fenway, Boston, MA, with pickup available for your meal.

Order online

Pizza

Sicilian Pizza

$28.99

This Sicilian-style pizza has a thick crust and optional toppings.

“Best pizza ever! Love the square and thick Sicilian. Great buffalo wings too!”

Lg 16" Gourmet Pizza

A 16-inch pizza with a selection of specialty styles available.

“Love this place. Cappy's has the best pizza in Boston!”

XXL 20" Italian Pizza

$21.99

A 20-inch pizza with optional toppings or a calzone conversion.

“Slices bigger than my face. Hot, delicious and definitely filling. Buffalo chicken and pepperoni were both delish.”

Lg 16" Italian Pizza

$15.99

This large 16-inch pizza has optional toppings or can be made a calzone.

“Great, quick late night pizza delivery - hit the spot after a long day of travel!”

Pasta

Pasta W/Grilled Chicken, Broccoli & Alfredo Sauce

$18.99

Chicken, broccoli, and Alfredo sauce over pasta; choose spaghetti or ziti.

Pasta W/Meatballs

$17.99

Meatballs served with pasta; spaghetti or ziti are available as choices.

Pasta W/Chicken Cutlet

$17.99

Pasta served with a chicken cutlet, with spaghetti or ziti available.

Stuffed Shells

$15.99

Pasta shells filled with cheese and served with tomato sauce.

Subs

Meatball Sub

$11.99+

Meatballs in a sub roll, with a required choice of small or large.

Chicken Parm Sub

$11.99+

Breaded chicken, tomato sauce, and melted cheese in a sub roll.

“Great slice, great chicken Parm sub, good price, nice service. Can't ask for much more from this out-of-towner's perspective.”

Sandwiches

Chicken Pesto Panini

$11.99

A pressed sandwich filled with chicken and pesto.

Caprese Panini

$9.99

A pressed panini with mozzarella, tomato, and basil.

Made with Care at Cappy's Pizza & Subs

At Cappy's Pizza & Subs, Italian food includes pasta with mushrooms, peppers, and onions, plus shrimp with broccoli and Alfredo. Paninis pair chicken with pesto or ham with Swiss cheese.

Pasta W/Meatballs is available with spaghetti. Italian Panini offers banana peppers as an add-on, while Meatball Sub comes in a large size and can be topped with cheese or cooked onions.

Order your meal in Fenway, Boston, MA for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Lg 16" Italian Pizza offers Italian sausage and black olive toppings, with the option to turn your pizza into a calzone.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular Italian food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Lg 16" Gourmet Pizza — The large pizza measures 16 inches, with specialty styles available including chicken, vegetable, Hawaiian, and Margherita varieties.
XXL 20" Italian Pizza — Choose optional toppings across the 20-inch pizza, with a listed customization to make it a calzone instead.
Lg 16" Italian Pizza — The 16-inch pizza has optional choices including chicken, vegetables, meats, and extra cheese; it can also be changed to a calzone.
Sicilian Pizza — Sicilian pizza is known for its thick, breadlike crust; optional toppings include meats, vegetables, and extra cheese.
Sm 12" Italian Pizza — This 12-inch pizza offers optional toppings, including meats and vegetables, and can be changed into a calzone.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for italian food throughout the Fenway, Boston area. Order your italian food online for convenient pickup or delivery.