Milkshakes in Fenway, Boston

Chocolate and vanilla milkshakes at Cappy's Pizza & Subs in Fenway, Boston, MA offer familiar flavors for your next pickup order.

Order online

Milkshakes to Try

milkshake vanilla

Vanilla milkshake with optional banana, caramel, or chocolate choices.

Oreo Vanilla Milkshake$9.98A vanilla milkshake paired with Oreo for a familiar cookies-and-cream-style flavor.
Strawberry Vanilla Milkshake$9.98A vanilla milkshake paired with strawberry for a sweet, fruity flavor.
Chocolate Vanilla Milkshake$9.98A vanilla milkshake paired with chocolate for a classic chocolate-and-vanilla flavor.
Reese’s Cup Vanilla Milkshake$9.98A vanilla milkshake paired with Reese’s Cup for a peanut butter and chocolate flavor.
Nutella Vanilla Milkshake$10.98A vanilla milkshake paired with Nutella for a rich hazelnut and chocolate flavor.
Cookie Dough Vanilla Milkshake$9.98A vanilla milkshake paired with cookie dough for a sweet, cookie-inspired flavor.

milkshake chocolate

$7.99

A chocolate milkshake served as a cold, blended drink.

Meet Cappy's Pizza & Subs

At Cappy's Pizza & Subs, milkshakes span chocolate and vanilla flavors; the vanilla offering also has fruit, candy, coffee, and dessert options, including coconut and chocolate sprinkles.

You can order milkshake chocolate or milkshake vanilla. For the vanilla choice, options include banana and blueberries for fruit flavors, plus Butterfinger and fudge brownie for dessert flavors.

Visit Fenway, Boston, MA for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Your vanilla drink has more flavor options, including cookie dough, cheesecake, and caramel, alongside chocolate chip and coffee.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular milkshakes options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the drink options we recommend most often.

milkshake vanilla — This vanilla milkshake can be customized with choices such as blueberries, cookie dough, coconut, or fudge brownie.
milkshake chocolate — This cold milkshake has chocolate flavor; the listing provides no additional ingredients, size, or customization details.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for milkshakes throughout the Fenway, Boston area. Order your milkshakes online for convenient pickup or delivery.